AI-Powered Editorial Intelligence

The Future of
Manuscript Screening
Starts Here

Five AI modules. One unified platform. Ethical Shield empowers journal editors with intelligent pre-review screening, integrity verification, reviewer discovery, and evidence-based editorial decisions.

0 AI Modules
0 Workflow States
70% Issues Caught Pre-Review
24/7 Automated Screening
editorial.ethicalshield.net
Dashboard
Manuscripts
Reviewers
Integrity
Editorial Dashboard Live
247 Total Submissions
189 Screening Passed
12 Integrity Flags
34 Pending Review
Manuscript Status Modules Risk
Impact of AI on Clinical Decision-Making... Screening Low
Meta-Analysis of Vaccine Efficacy in... Under Review None
Novel Biomarkers for Early Detection of... Flagged High
Longitudinal Study of Sleep Patterns... Accepted None

Built for the standards that academic publishing demands

COPE Aligned
OpenAlex Integration
GDPR Ready
ORCID Verified
Full Audit Trail

Editorial offices are overwhelmed.
AI makes them unstoppable.

Journals face mounting pressure: more submissions, rising fraud, reviewer fatigue, and the expectation of faster turnaround. Ethical Shield transforms the editorial workflow with intelligent automation that augments human judgment.

The Problem

  • Manual screening takes days per manuscript
  • Integrity issues slip through to peer review
  • Finding qualified reviewers is time-consuming
  • Reviewer reports vary wildly in quality
  • Revision compliance is impossible to verify at scale

The Solution

  • Automated screening in minutes, not days
  • AI-powered integrity verification catches fraud early
  • Evidence-based reviewer discovery via OpenAlex
  • Review quality assessment with AI suspicion detection
  • Automated revision compliance tracking

Five intelligent modules.
One powerful pipeline.

Each module specializes in a critical dimension of editorial quality. Together, they form a comprehensive AI screening cascade that catches issues before they reach peer review.

01
Pre-Screening Automated

Technical Check

Validates manuscript structure, metadata completeness, and policy compliance against configurable journal requirements. From ethics statements to citation style conformance.

Ethics & consent verification
Funding & COI disclosure check
Citation style detection (APA7, Vancouver, IEEE)
Configurable journal policies
Technical Check Results
Ethics Statement PASS
Author Contributions PASS
Data Availability WEAK
Funding Disclosure PASS
COI Declaration PASS
02
Integrity AI + Database

Submission Integrity

The most comprehensive integrity analysis module. Detects prior publication, duplicate submission, author verification anomalies, self-citation manipulation, and data inconsistencies using OpenAlex and AI.

Prior version & overlap detection
Author verification via ORCID & OpenAlex
Self-citation & bibliography analysis
Novelty classification & risk scoring
Risk Assessment HIGH RISK
Overlap Score: 78%
Near-duplicate detected via DOI
Author affiliation mismatch
ORCID verification passed
Overlap Type Substantial Overlap
03
Discovery AI + OpenAlex

Reviewer Finder

Discovers qualified peer reviewers by analyzing manuscript topics against the global academic literature. Intelligent scoring filters for relevance, recency, citations, and conflicts of interest.

AI-driven topic extraction & search
Multi-factor scoring (topic, recency, citations)
Automatic COI filtering
Up to 15 candidates with rationale
Top Reviewer Candidates
AR
Dr. A. Richardson University of Example
92
MD
Prof. M. Delacroix Institut Pasteur Demo
87
SO
Dr. S. Okonkwo Demo Research Institute
84
LV
Dr. L. Varga Sample University
79
04
Decision Support AI-Driven

Editorial Assistant

AI-powered decision support that synthesizes reviewer reports, assesses review quality, detects AI-generated reviews, and drafts editor decision letters. COPE-aligned recommendations with full transparency.

Review validity & quality assessment
AI review suspicion detection
COPE-aligned decision recommendations
Auto-drafted decision & reviewer letters
Recommendation Major Revision
Reviewer 1 Quality: 82/100
Anchoring STRONG
Reviewer 2 Quality: 41/100
Anchoring WEAK
AI-generated review suspected
View Decision Letter
05
Verification AI + Diff Analysis

Revision Check

Compares revised manuscripts against reviewer comments and response letters. Evidence-backed verification ensures authors actually addressed each concern, with section-level change mapping and overclaim detection.

Response letter parsing & matching
Manuscript diff analysis (V1 vs V2)
Evidence-backed compliance verification
Overclaim & inadequate revision detection
Revision Compliance 76% Verified
"Add control group to methodology" VERIFIED
"Expand discussion of limitations" VERIFIED
"Rewrite statistical analysis section" PARTIAL
"Address Reviewer 2's concern on bias" NOT FOUND

A dedicated space for authors.
From submission to publication.

Authors get their own secure portal to submit manuscripts, track progress, respond to reviews, and manage revisions — all without touching the editorial workspace.

Self-Registration

Secure accounts with ORCID integration, institutional affiliation, and reusable profiles across submissions.

Guided 4-Step Submission

Metadata, authors, compliance declarations (ethics, COI, funding, AI use, data availability), and file uploads — structured and validated.

Live Submission Tracking

Dashboard with status indicators, action-required alerts, and full visibility into the editorial pipeline for each manuscript.

Revision & Resubmission

Download reviewer reports, upload revised manuscripts with response letters, and track revision rounds — all from a deadline-enforced portal.

Reviewer Preferences

Suggest up to 3 preferred reviewers and exclude up to 3 — with name, email, affiliation, and expertise fields.

JD
Author Workspace Submissions & Revisions
6Total
2Active
3Accepted
1Action
Comparative Policy Analysis in EU... Under Review
Socioeconomic Impact of Digital... Revision Due
Constitutional Framework for AI... Accepted
Submission Flow
1 Metadata
2 Authors
3 Declaration
4 Upload

From acceptance to publication.
Production-ready pipeline.

Manage the entire post-acceptance workflow: production queues, PDF uploads, DOI assignment, issue management, and one-click publishing to your journal website.

Production Queue
All Awaiting In Production Published
8 Awaiting
3 In Production
42 Published
Accepted
Awaiting
In Production
Published
Analysis of Electoral Systems... DOI: 10.XXXX/demo.2026.001
Awaiting
Administrative Law Reform in... Issue 1/2026 · pp. 12-34
In Production
Regional Security Dynamics in... Issue 1/2026 · Published 2026-03-15
Published

Production Queue

Track manuscripts from acceptance through production to publication. Filter by status, search by DOI, and manage the full pipeline.

Final PDF & Metadata

Upload publication-ready PDFs, assign DOIs, set page ranges, and finalize metadata for each accepted manuscript.

Issue Management

Create and manage journal issues — volumes, covers, first pages. Supports continuous publication and special issues.

One-Click Publish

Publish manuscripts to your journal website instantly. Articles appear on the public site with full metadata, DOI, and downloadable PDF.

Seamless peer review.
Zero friction for reviewers.

Reviewers receive a secure, token-based link by email. No account needed. Accept or decline, download the manuscript, upload the review report — all from one page.

RST Journal
Review Round 1
Manuscript Administrative Law Reform in the Context of European Integration...
Invited
Accepted
Under Review
Report Uploaded
Materials (unlocked)
manuscript_v1.docx Download
cover_letter.pdf Download
Upload Review Report
Deadline: April 18, 2026

Token-Based Access

No account needed. Reviewers receive a unique secure link by email — one click to access the portal.

Accept / Decline

72-hour acceptance window. On accept, manuscript materials unlock. On decline, the editor is notified instantly.

Download & Upload

Download manuscript, cover letter, and supplementary files. Upload the review report when ready — all in one page.

Deadline & Reminders

Automatic reminder 48h before deadline. 3-day grace period after. Portal closes automatically on completion.

Multi-Round Reviews

Support for multiple revision-review cycles. Each round tracked separately with independent deadlines and reports.

Your journal, published online.
Professional. Indexed. Accessible.

Accepted manuscripts are published on your journal's public website with full metadata, DOI, downloadable PDF, figures, tables, and SEO-optimized citation tags — ready for indexing.

Public Article Pages

Each article gets a dedicated page with title, authors, abstract, full text, figures, tables, references, and supplementary materials.

DOI & Citation Metadata

SEO-optimized meta tags (citation_doi, citation_author, citation_journal_title) for Google Scholar and academic indexing.

PDF Download & Archives

Readers download the publication PDF directly. Full issue archives organized by volume and year.

Author Notification

Corresponding author receives email with article link, DOI, and PDF download — automatically on publication.

RST Journal
Research Article Vol. 5, Issue 1/2026

Administrative Law Reform in the Context of European Integration

Author A, Author B, Author C
DOI: 10.XXXX/rst.2026.001 March 2026 pp. 12-34
Abstract

This study examines the reform of administrative law within the framework of European integration, focusing on...

Download PDF Full Text

One platform, complete lifecycle.
From submission to publication.

Every actor — author, editor, reviewer, reader — interacts through the same system. Nothing falls through the cracks. Every step is tracked, audited, and automated.

Author Submits Registers, fills metadata, authors, compliance declarations, uploads manuscript via the Author Portal.
Author Portal
AI Screening Editor runs Technical Check and Submission Integrity modules. Flags risks, verifies author credentials via OpenAlex & ORCID.
Editorial Platform
Reviewer Discovery & Invitation AI finds qualified reviewers via OpenAlex. Editor sends email invitations with secure portal links.
Editorial Platform
Peer Review Reviewers accept/decline via token link, download manuscript, and upload review reports. Automatic deadline reminders.
Reviewer Portal
Editorial Decision AI Editorial Assistant assesses review quality, detects AI reviews, and recommends decisions. Editor sends decision letter. Multiple revision rounds supported.
Editorial Platform
Revision cycle (author resubmits, new review round)
Production Queue Accepted manuscript enters production. Final PDF upload, DOI assignment, metadata finalization, issue assignment.
Editorial Platform
Published Online Article goes live on journal website with full text, DOI, PDF. Author notified automatically with publication link.
Public Website

Built for editorial teams
who demand excellence.

Real-Time Dashboard

Live editorial overview with risk stratification, module status indicators, decision distribution, and performance trends.

Editorial Memory

Learns from historical decisions to identify recurring patterns, suggest similar cases, and improve editorial consistency over time.

Author & Reviewer Profiles

Centralized directory with publication history, expertise tracking, ORCID integration, and conflict of interest detection.

Complete Audit Trail

Every action, decision, and module run is logged with timestamps. Full compliance transparency for journal accreditation.

Automated Communications

Decision letters, reviewer invitations, deadline reminders, and revision requests — all auto-drafted and ready to send.

Configurable Policies

Each journal defines its own requirements: required, advisory, or ignore. Ethical Shield adapts to your editorial standards.

0 AI Modules Technical Check, Submission Integrity, Reviewer Finder, Editorial Assistant, Revision Check
0 Compliance Declarations Ethics, funding, COI, AI use, data availability, consent, originality, and more
0 User Roles Editor Admin, Editor in Chief, Managing Editor, Assistant Editor, Viewer, Author, Reviewer
0 Workflow States From Submitted through Screening, Review, Revision, Decision, Production, and Publication

Built by an editor,
for editors.

Ethical Shield was not designed in a vacuum. It was built by someone who has spent over a decade on both sides of academic publishing — as a researcher, as an editor-in-chief, and as a quality evaluator for international journal directories.

FM

Flavius Cristian Mărcău

PhD · Lecturer · Journal Editor · Software Developer

Târgu Jiu, Romania

"I built Ethical Shield because I knew exactly what editors need — and exactly what existing tools were missing."

Academic Background

PhD — Babeș-Bolyai University Cluj-Napoca
Lecturer PhD — "Constantin Brâncuși" University Course holder: Ethics & Academic Integrity
Gold Medal — INVENTCOR International Exhibition
150+ Publications
15+ Years in publishing
20+ Q1 and Q2 journals
DOAJ Associate Editor

Ready to transform your editorial workflow?

See how Ethical Shield can help your journal screen faster, verify deeper, and decide with confidence.